Full description not available
J**O
Great read
This is a fantastic book and a gripping read! If you enjoy reading about WWII, then I highly recommend this book. It's unbelievable that this story isn't famous as the Great Escape. This isn't just another war story, but a book with amazing strength of characters and determination. Hard to believe it's true. Download now and get into it!
J**S
The Simple Realities of a WWII Escape
Despite being written by someone who is neither a professional writer nor an historian, this book is an engaging and rewarding read. It tells the story of three men who escaped from a German prison camp in WWII and made their way back to Britain. Crucially, it is written by one of those who made the escape; it is not "ghost-written" but expressed in his own words and in his own way. John McCallum (no relation to this reviewer) waited many years before writing the book, feeling that he was bound by the Official Secrets Act, but obviously his memory was still clear. The great strengths of the book are its simplicity and clarity. He does not indulge in fashionable moralising but instead sticks to his story, which is presented strictly from the viewpoint of the three "ordinary lads" from Glasgow. His purpose is to tell how it was done, without puffed-up heroics and without invented introspection. He is also quite honest in his portrayal of himself, his comrades, and those involved in the escape. The three men had signed up together in the Territorial Army and were later mobilised and sent to France in 1940, where they were captured. The author is full of praise, for instance, for the German and captive English doctors who treated his wound, not only as first aid but with complicated surgery that ensured he would not be crippled. He and his friends were sent to prison camps in the east of Germany and in Bohemia, where they spent several years mostly on outside work parties, which allowed them to work on farms and small businesses in what was still a quiet rural area. When they finally decided to make an escape, it depended vitally on McCallum's local paramour, who provided essential intelligence, clothing, food, and even documents, and on support from French and other forced labour camps. During the escape, walking and taking trains north to a Baltic port from which they sneaked on board a merchant boat going to Sweden, they encountered numerous situations in which they fully expected to be exposed and arrested - but weren't; McCallum attributes this success to "luck", which was on their side most of the time. It also seems that sometimes they succeeded because they were not trying to be too clever or sophisticated in their plans, but rather, were going more on instinct. They survived one bit of bad luck when they were coming into a train station to discover that it was swarming with Gestapo and military police because the now-famous "Great Escape" had just occurred and security was very tight indeed. It is a refreshingly honest tale, which makes an important and unique addition to WWII escape literature.
A**H
a gripping read
The book was recommended to me and I found it a really good,could not put it down, read it from cover to cover. It did not dwell on the hardship of being a POW more an account of the mindset of these men during a long period of captivity.Given the interest in the recent released "Railway Man" this would make a great candidate for the big screen.
P**S
Good story, poorly written
This has the makings of a great story but the way it is written lets it down badly. The story unfolds as a matter of fact, with no sense of the drama and suspense, never mind fear, that the main characters must no doubt have felt. Easy to read but easy to forget, unfortunately.
H**9
Enjoyable Adventure
I quite enjoyed this book, it flowed quite well once you got passed the initial section on PoW's and their treatment.It is a really interesting story and gives another perspective on Allied PoW's conditions as it seems the author missed most of the bad experiences written about in other books. Either that or he plays it down quite well.My only complaint is that the escape section of the book is not as detailed or as long as I thought it would be. This is possible down to the straight forward route they picked but still would have been nice for it to be fleshed out.Even so I would still recommend giving this a read as it is worth the time.
D**E
Great escape story
Excellent , just missing a tad more detail but so what! , recommended if you have any interest in W W 2
B**N
An inspiring escape
I found this a very hard to put down book about a POW escape I had never heard of until I noticed it advertised on Amazon.I liked the way the author described various encounters and happenings ,he was also not bothered about giving his opinion about various people and said it as he saw it.I gave this book 4 stars because there are a couple of unanswered questions which would have been interesting to know.Great book though
A**R
Three friends trials to escape
The author maintained the thrill throughout. The unbelievable luck they experienced helped to achieve their aim but not without their own efforts to stay ahead of the game.
Trustpilot
1 month ago
1 day ago